CMR vs SMR Drives: Conventional Magnetic Recording Explained

CMR vs SMR explained: how conventional and shingled magnetic recording write data, why SMR slows RAID rebuilds and ZFS resilvers, and how to check which a drive is.

Topics: CMR, SMR, Conventional Magnetic Recording, Shingled Magnetic Recording, RAID, ZFS

The short answer

CMR drives use conventional magnetic recording: each track is written with a gap beside it, so any sector can be rewritten in place. SMR (shingled magnetic recording) overlaps tracks like roof shingles to fit more data on a platter, so rewriting one sector means rewriting a whole band of tracks. Reads are the same on both. The difference shows up under sustained random writes, which is exactly what a RAID rebuild or a ZFS resilver produces. For any redundant array, buy CMR, and confirm it from the maker's own CMR/SMR list rather than from the part number.

This guide is part of our series on drive formats. The companion piece on sector sizes, 512e vs 4Kn vs 512n, covers the other spec that decides whether a replacement drive fits an array.

How CMR and SMR write data

On a CMR drive the write head lays down tracks side by side with a small guard gap between them. Each track can be rewritten without touching its neighbours, so the drive simply seeks to the sector and writes it.

SMR removes most of those gaps. Western Digital's zoned-storage documentation describes it as writing "the tracks in an overlapping manner". Each new track partly covers the one before it. That is how SMR fits more tracks on the same platter, and it is also its cost: WD notes that when a sector "has to be modified or re-written, then the entire band of tracks" has to be rewritten with it, because the data may sit under another shingle.

Reading is unaffected. WD states that SMR hard disks "provide true random-read capability", so the trade-off is on the write side only.

Three kinds of SMR

TypeWho manages the shinglesWhat the host sees
Drive-managed (DM-SMR)The drive firmwareAn ordinary disk; no software changes needed
Host-aware (HA-SMR)Shared; the host can helpAn ordinary disk that also reports its zones
Host-managed (HM-SMR)The host softwareZones that accept only sequential writes; software must be written for it

Almost every SMR drive sold as a normal desktop or NAS drive is drive-managed. WD's documentation calls the drive-managed model "backwards-compatible and transparent to hosts". That transparency is the problem for buyers: nothing in the operating system, the RAID controller or the NAS warns you that the disk is shingled. Host-managed drives are a different product class, used in large storage systems whose software writes sequentially by design.

Why SMR hurts RAID rebuilds, ZFS and NAS

A drive-managed SMR disk has to do that band rewriting itself, in the background, and it needs idle time to keep up. A desktop that writes in bursts gives it plenty. A workload where the writes never stop does not.

A rebuild or resilver is the worst case. The replacement disk receives a continuous stream of writes for hours or days, so it never gets the idle time it needs to tidy its bands. Western Digital said this directly about its own SMR WD Red drives: the sustained random writes of a ZFS resilver cause "a lack of idle time", and it pointed write-intensive and ZFS users to its CMR models instead.

The ZFS maintainers go further. The OpenZFS hardware documentation states that "DM-SMR drives are therefore not recommended for ZFS pools" and that CMR drives "should be preferred for any redundant pool". iXsystems, which makes TrueNAS, says drive-managed and host-aware SMR drives work poorly there, warning of "degraded write performance and longer, less reliable resilver operations", and that host-managed SMR is not supported at all.

Toshiba makes the same point for NAS use in general: SMR affects write speed in uses such as network-attached storage, "where continuous random writing regularly occurs."

Where SMR is fine: Seagate says SMR "is best suited for workloads that are sequential or easily sequentialized", for example a single archive disk or a backup target that is written once and read later. The capacity per dollar is the point of the technology. It is the wrong choice for a member of a parity array.

How to tell whether a drive is CMR or SMR

Do not trust the part number. OpenZFS warns that the recording technology "is frequently not stated in the model number", and recommends confirming the exact model with the manufacturer. Use the makers' own lists:

Western Digital. WD lists its WD Red 2 TB, 3 TB, 4 TB and 6 TB drives (EFAX part numbers) as drive-managed SMR. iXsystems adds that 8 TB and larger EFAX drives are CMR. WD Red Plus is the name WD now uses for its CMR WD Red drives, and WD Red Pro is CMR. Our WD Red and Purple hub lists the Red Plus and Red Pro part numbers we carry.

Seagate. Seagate's CMR/SMR list shows:

  • IronWolf, IronWolf Pro, SkyHawk and SkyHawk AI: CMR at every listed capacity.
  • BarraCuda 3.5-inch: 4 TB and 8 TB are SMR; 12 TB to 24 TB are CMR.
  • BarraCuda and FireCuda 2.5-inch: the listed 1 TB to 4 TB drives are SMR.
  • Exos 3.5-inch: 4 TB to 24 TB are CMR, plus HAMR CMR at 28 TB to 32 TB. Seagate also lists some 32 TB, 36 TB and 44 TB Exos as SMR.

So check the exact model even within Exos. See Seagate IronWolf and SkyHawk and Seagate Exos. Our Seagate 8TB hard drives and Seagate 4TB hard drives pages group our listings at those sizes by family.

Toshiba. Toshiba names the P300 4 TB and 6 TB (bulk HDWD240UZSVA and HDWD260UZSVA) and the L200 1 TB and 2 TB laptop drives as SMR. It points NAS buyers to the N300, which does not use SMR.

What the operating system can and cannot tell you: a host-managed SMR drive is a zoned device that software has to be written for, so you would know if you had one. A drive-managed SMR drive is, in WD's words, transparent to the host; it looks like any other disk. So for the common case, the maker's list is the only reliable check.

Mixing CMR and SMR in one array

If an array is already CMR, replace a failed member with CMR. A single drive-managed SMR member can slow every rebuild that touches it, and with ZFS it can stretch a resilver long enough to leave the pool exposed to a second failure. If you find an SMR drive already in a redundant array, plan to swap it for CMR when it is next convenient. Do not wait until another disk fails.

Most data-centre and NAS-class lines are CMR, but check the list for the exact model. Some listings make it easy by printing the recording method in the name: on our site, the WD Red Pro 26 TB (WD260KFGX) for NAS use and the WD Purple 14 TB (WD140PURZ) for recorders both state CMR. For data-centre drives across brands, the enterprise hard drives hub groups the SAS and SATA lines.

Recording method and sector format are separate specs

CMR and SMR describe how bits are laid on the platter. Sector format (512n, 512e or 4Kn) describes how the drive presents its blocks to the host. A drive has one of each, and both matter when you replace an array member:

Common questions

Is SMR the same as "SMR-enabled" or "zoned"? Zoned usually means host-managed or host-aware SMR, where the drive exposes zones to software. A normal consumer SMR drive is drive-managed and exposes nothing.

Can firmware fix SMR rebuild times? Firmware decides how the drive manages its bands, and WD's documentation notes that drive-managed SMR performance "depend[s] on the internal disk firmware implementation". It cannot remove the need to rewrite whole bands, so sustained random writes stay slower than on CMR.

Is every enterprise drive CMR? Not automatically. Seagate's own list includes SMR models in its highest-capacity Exos range, so check the maker's list for the exact model.

Not sure what is in your array? Email sales@prodisknetwork.com with the existing drive's part number and the controller or NAS model, and we will look it up on the maker's list before you order.

Parts referenced in this guide

Every part below is named in the article above.

Part of

Enterprise Storage Hub

View all 178 pages →

Enterprise HDDs, SSDs, NVMe, SAS, SATA, RAID controllers, drive caddies and storage array hardware.